Regional Solutions to Urban Revitalization:

A Policy Forum on Alternative Locations for a Detroit Metro Park

 

Gerald R Ford School of Public Policy ** Integrated Policy Exercise ** January 2004

 

Home | Metro Park Proposals | Outside Experts | Research Links | Schedule | Student Assignments | IPE Deliverables


DAILY SCHEDULE
(Updated January 3, 2003)


MONDAY, 5 JANUARY 2004


8:30 - 12:00
Guided Bus Tour of Detroit
Meet on Tappan St. outside of the Lorch Hall

12:00 - 1:30
Lunch and Speakers
Senator Carl Levin, U.S. Senate
Walter Watkins, Chief Development Officer, City of Detroit
Detroit Historical Museum

1:45 - 2:15
Opening remarks by Prof. Gerber and Dean Blank

2:15 - 3:15
Tour musem exhibits
(Park Advocates meet to begin planning for Tuesday's presentations)

3:15 - 5:00
Complete Detroit bus tour and return to Ann Arbor


Individual background memos (Assignment #1) due by 8:30 am on Coursetools


TUESDAY, 6 JANUARY 2004

8:15- 8:45
Video viewing. Only for students unable to attend bus tour.
450 Lorch Hall

9:00 - 9:15
Registration
Ballroom entrance

9:15 - 10:00
Welcome and Overview of Schedule and Rules
Ballroom

10:00-10:30
Introduction of Interest Group Experts
Ballroom

10:30 - 12:00
Interest/Commissioner/Advocate Group Meetings
Break out as indicated below.

Interest Group Meetings with outside experts
Anderson ABCD, Parker
Each of the six Interest Groups meets with an outside expert from their interest group area to better understand the Interest Group's key issues, political considerations, current coalitions and goals.

Commissioner Group Meetings
Pond ABC
Commissioners meet collectively to discuss regional interests and learn parliamentary procedures.

Advocate Group Meetings
Wolverine ABC
Advocate Groups continue to plan for public presentation of proposals at lunch.

12:00 - 1:00
Luncheon Speaker (Lunch provided)
Ballroom
Robert Marans, Washtenaw County HCMA Commissioner and UM Professor of Urban Planning

1:00 - 2:00
HCMA Public Hearing
Ballroom
Each Advocate Group presents a summary of its preferred proposal at the public hearing of the HCMA and explains the merits of the proposal to persuade Commissioners and Stakeholders to invest in a particular proposal.

2:00 - 2:30
Introduction of HCMA Commissioners/ Detroit City Government Representatives
Ballroom

2:30 - 3:45
Interest/Commissioner/Advocate Group Meetings
Break out as indicated below

Interest Group Meetings
Anderson ABCD, Parker
Each Interest Group meets to discuss and write a 3-page position paper assessing the strengths and weaknesses of each proposal according to the benefits and alignment with the Interest Group. These position papers are due at 9:00 on Wednesday morning on Coursetools and will be the basis of the public hearing on Wednesday morning.

Commissioner Group Meetings
Pond ABC
Each of the eight Commissioner Groups meets with an outside expert from the regional areas that the Commissioner Groups serve to better understand the region's political considerations, changing demographics, key players, etc.

Advocate Group Meetings
Wolverine ABC
Advocate Groups meet with Detroit City Government reps (see Commissioner Group Meetings above).

3:45 - 4:00
Coffee Break
Ballroom

4:00 - 5:00
Interest/Commissioner/Advocate Group Meetings
Break out as indicated below

Interest Group Meetings
Anderson ABCD, Parker
Continue meetings started at 2:30pm.

Commissioner Group Meetings
Pond ABC
Commissioner Groups each write a 1-page press release on their region's interest in urban revitalization and a Detroit Metropark. Due 9:00 am Wednesday on Coursetools.

Advocate Group Meetings
Wolverine ABC
Advocate Groups each write a 2-page memo detailing a strategy for forming a coalition in support of their preferred proposal, including likely supporters. Due 9:00 a.m. Wednesday on Coursetools.


WEDNESDAY, 7 JANUARY 2004

Assignment #2 due by 9:00 am on Coursetools (except Park Advocates)

9:00 - 10:30
HCMA Public Hearing
Ballroom
Interest Groups present their positions on each of the 4 proposals in 20 minutes speeches to full student body.

10:30 - 10:45
Coffee Break
Ballroom

10:45- 11:30
Continuation of Public Hearing
Ballroom
Interest Groups present their positions on each of the 4 proposals in 20 minutes speeches to full student body.

11:30 - 1:00
Interest/Commissioner/Advocate Group Meetings

Interest Group Meetings
Wolverine ABC
Each Interest Group creates a strategy for coalition-building around a preferred proposal.

Commissioner Group Meeting
2105B
Commissioner Groups hold private meetings to discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the proposals and determine initial group support for each proposal.

Advocate Group Meetings
Parker
Each Advocate Group meets briefly to discuss the findings from the public hearing. The remainder of this session should be spent lobbying Interest Groups.

1:00 - 3:00
Luncheon Speaker (Lunch provided)
Ballroom
Paul Tait, SEMCOG
Matthew Cullen, General Motors and Riverfront Conservancy

3:00 - 5:00
Regional/Commissioner/Advocate Group Meetings

Regional Group Meetings of Interest Groups
Livingston County: 2105 B
Macomb County: Pendleton
Oakland County: Pond ABC
Southeast Michigan: Pendleton
Statewide: Pendleton
Washtenaw County: 2105 B
Wayne County:
Pond ABC
Detroit: Wolverine A
Regional Groups debate the four proposals and try to create a consensus around one or more proposals.

Commissioner Group Meetings
Parker
Each Commissioner Group writes a 3-page position paper on all of the proposals, including an analysis of a preferred proposal. These papers form the basis for discussion at the HCMA Meeting and are due at 10:00 am Thursday on Coursetools.

Advocate Group Meetings
Wolverine A
Advocate Groups meet with the Interest Groups from the Detroit region to debate the proposals and try to create a consensus around one or more proposals for Detroit.


THURSDAY, 8 JANUARY 2004

Assignment #3 (Commissioners only) due by 10:00 am on Coursetools
Assignment #2 (Park Advocates only) due by 9:00 am on Coursetools

10:00 - 11:30
Regional Constituent Meetings

Each of the Commissioners holds an open session to gain input from Stakeholders and Advocates.
Livingston County: Anderson B
Macomb County: Anderson C
Oakland County: Wolverine B
Southeast Michigan: Anderson D
Statewide: Anderson D
Washtenaw County: Anderson A
Wayne County: Wolverine C
Detroit: Wolverine A

11:30 - 11:45
Coffee Break
Ballroom

11:45 - 1:00
HCMA Meeting (Led by the HCMA Chairperson from Macomb County)
Ballroom
Commissioners discuss alternative proposals.

Meeting Format & Rules:

Each Commissioner group has 4 minutes to reveal their preferred park and any other amenable options.

After initial speeches, anyone can talk by flipping up his/her name card. Commissioners can pose a question or state a comment. Comments and/or questions must be 3 minutes or less.

The Chairperson calls on Commissioners in the order that they flip up their name cards and enforces the time restrictions.

The Chairperson may wish to appoint a Timekeeper to assist him/her.

1:00 - 2:30
Working lunch
Lobbying/coalition building (Lunch not provided)

2:30 - 3:15
HCMA Meeting
Ballroom
Commissioners vote for preferred proposal.

Voting Format and Rules:

Each Commissioner has up to 3 minutes to give brief remarks and cast one vote for his/her preferred proposal.

The winning vote will receive a plurality (majority is not necessary)

In the case of a tie, the Detroit Commissioner will cast a tie-breaking vote.

3:15 - 3:45
Prepare for Regional Referendums
Ballroom
Stakeholders decide how to vote on the one proposal approved by the HCMA Commissioners.

3:45 - 4:30
Regional Referendums
Pendleton
Each stakeholder votes yes or no on the proposal passed by the HCMA. The referendums are held by region.

Voting Format and Rules:

All stakeholders should sit together by region.

Each stakeholder will vote yes or no on the one proposal previously selected by the Commissioners.

A majority of voters must be in favor of the proposal in order for the referendum to pass in that region.

4:30 - 5:30
Debrief
Pendleton
Paul Courant, Professor and Provost, University of Michigan

5:30 - 7:00
IPE Banquet
Ballroom




Monday

 

Tuesday

 

Wednesday

 

Thursday

 

Printable Format (PDF)